🐟 Pick Your Fish by Cooking Style

Tap a style to see the best fish and quick tips. Simple, mobile-friendly, and ready for tonight’s dinner.

🔥Grilling — How to Get Perfect Fish Every Time
Tuna (Big Eye, Yellowfin, Bluefin)Black Sea Bass SwordfishMahi Mahi Snapper (whole/fillet) Grouper Amberjack Red Drum (Redfish) Wahoo Sheepshead Pompano Rockfish / Stripe Bass

Grilling fish is all about heat, timing, and a little patience. Follow these simple steps for delicious, flaky results every time.

🧂 Before You Grill

  • Pat it dry: Always dry the fish well with paper towels. Moisture causes steam, which prevents browning and makes fish stick.
  • Keep the skin on (if possible): The skin helps hold the fish together and crisps beautifully on the grill.
  • Avoid over-marinating: If using citrus or other acidic marinades, limit to 15–20 minutes.
  • Clean and oil the grates: A clean, oiled grill prevents sticking and gives better grill marks.
  • Preheat to high heat: Set your grill to 400–450°F (medium-high to high) for a quick sear and easy release.

🔥 While You Grill

  • Be patient: Let the fish cook mostly on one side — wait until the edges turn opaque before flipping.
  • Don’t force it: The fish will naturally release from the grates when it’s ready. If it sticks, give it more time.
  • Use the right tool: A wide, thin-bladed fish spatula (or two) makes flipping smoother and cleaner.
  • Let it rest: After grilling, rest the fish for 3–5 minutes so the juices redistribute.

💡 Buddy’s Tip: Brush with olive oil and a squeeze of lemon before grilling — it adds flavor, prevents sticking, and creates a golden crust.

🥘Baking / Roasting — Easy, Flavorful, and Foolproof
SalmonCod / Haddock GrouperSnapper HalibutFlounder Bronzini (Branzino)Ocean Perch Tilapia / SwaiCatfish WhitingPorgy Black Sea Bass

Baking or roasting fish is simple and reliable. Pat the fish completely dry, lightly oil the pan or use parchment to prevent sticking, and preheat to 375°F.

👩🏾‍🍳 How to Season Your Fish

  • Pat dry: Removes excess moisture for better browning.
  • Add oil: Brush/drizzle olive oil so seasonings stick.
  • Season generously: Rub herbs/spices on both sides.
  • Add aromatics: Top with garlic, lemon slices, or herbs; add some to the pan.
  • Optional marinade: Chill 30–60 minutes for deeper flavor.

🌿 Flavor Ideas to Try

  • Lemon-garlic-butter: Melt butter with garlic + lemon; pour over fish before baking.
  • Lemon-dill: Dill, lemon zest/juice, olive oil — great for salmon/trout.
  • Mediterranean: Oregano, basil, thyme, garlic powder; finish with lemon.
  • Herb bundle (whole fish): Stuff with lemon, parsley, oregano, garlic.

Tip: Bake until the fish flakes easily — 10–12 min for thin fillets or 15–18 min for thicker cuts; rest a few minutes before serving.

🍤Frying (crispy & flaky)
WhitingCatfishFlounder CroakerPerch (Yellow)Snapper SpotsMullet / Jumping MulletOcean Perch SmeltPorgyFlorida BrimBlack Sea Bass
Tip: Season with Buddy’s Seafood Market Cape Cod Seasoning, then coat with Atkinson’s Seafood Breader (both at Buddy’s). Fry at 350°F until golden and crispy; serve with tartar or hot sauce.
💧Poaching / Steaming (gentle & moist)
FlounderCod Trout (Rainbow / Speckled) SalmonTilapia Black Cod (Sablefish)Halibut
Tip: Try a classic court bouillon (onion, lemon, herbs) or an Asian-style broth with ginger, cilantro, and chili. A white wine–butter stock adds richness; a light lemongrass + fish sauce broth is great for delicate fish.
🔥Broiling — Fast, Flavorful, and Perfectly Crisp
SalmonSwordfish Mahi MahiBluefish SnapperTuna (steaks/loin) GrouperKing Mackerel

Broil on a foil-lined pan about 6 inches from the heat for 8–10 minutes (depending on thickness). Season simply with salt, pepper, and garlic powder (paprika for color), or try a lemon–dill–tarragon blend for delicate fish. For richer fish like salmon, go classic with Old Bay or bold with a ginger–garlic–chili paste.

💡 Tips for Broiling Fish

  • Add Fat: Drizzle with olive oil or dot with butter to prevent sticking and aid browning.
  • Check Doneness: Flakes easily and reads 145°F internally.
  • Watch Closely: Broilers cook fast — check early to avoid overcooking.
💨Smoking (bold & rich)
SalmonMackerel (King / Spanish) BluefishTrout ShadButterfishRibbonfish
Tip: For a balanced rub, combine salt, brown sugar, garlic powder, and smoked paprika. Lemon + dill suit lighter fish; add cayenne, coriander, and allspice for a warm, spicy kick.

Need help choosing? Ask our team — we’ll match your recipe to the perfect fish.